Recorded live at the AMA Higher Ed Symposium, marketing leaders Kristin Nichols and Jeff Holeman share their playbook for defending brand awareness investments against the pressure for immediate performance metrics.
When campus leadership is hyper-focused on immediate enrollment metrics, advocating for long-term brand awareness can feel like an uphill battle. But as Jeff Holeman, CMO at the University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business, frequently reminds his stakeholders: “Awareness fuels performance. You can’t have one without the other.”
In a special on-location episode of Higher Voltage recorded at the AMA Higher Ed Symposium in Denver, host Kevin Tyler caught up with Holeman and Kristin Nichols, the first-ever CMO at the Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (MCLA). The two had just delivered a highly praised presentation on defending brand awareness and reputation inside performance-obsessed institutions.
Both leaders inherited scenarios where institutional dollars were heavily skewed toward lower-funnel performance marketing at the expense of brand building. The result was the same on both campuses: exorbitant cost-per-lead bloat, poor conversion rates, and a brand message that was entirely absent in key markets.
To turn the tide, Nichols and Holeman had to make data-driven cases to their respective leadership teams. Nichols used national survey data to prove that MCLA was essentially “silent in the market,” ultimately convincing leadership to reallocate two-thirds of their lead-purchasing budget into strengthening the website and building organic, omnichannel storytelling. Holeman used market research to demonstrate that despite the University of Florida’s massive footprint, the Warrington College of Business lacked the specific program awareness needed to compete against national heavyweights in new markets like Miami.
By successfully arguing that it takes multiple brand touchpoints to nurture a prospect over the typical two-year graduate enrollment cycle, both leaders secured the funding needed to build a brand foundation. Most importantly, those investments have paid off, with substantial increases in inquiries and enrolled students at both institutions.
Read the full transcript here
Kevin Tyler
Listen — this is our very first on-location recording of Higher Voltage. This feels like a moment for us. We are at the AMA Higher Ed Symposium in Denver, Colorado, here with two good friends who are presenting at AMA 2026: Jeff Holeman and Kristin Nichols. They are presenting on how to defend brand awareness and reputation inside a performance-based institution.
Kristin Nichols
Hi everyone, thanks Kevin. My name is Kristin Nichols and I’m thrilled to be back at AMA in Denver this year — beautiful backdrop. Just so you all know, I am the first chief marketing officer that MCLA has ever had. MCLA is Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, the public liberal arts institution in the state of Massachusetts, and I’m also a proud alum. I’m really excited to talk about what we’ve done there over the last almost three years to improve visibility for MCLA.
Jeff Holeman
And I’m Jeff Holeman. I’m the Chief Marketing Officer at the University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business. I’ve been there about three years now, and my focus is on brand and revenue-driving marketing initiatives.
Kevin Tyler
The conference presentation you did was perfect. It’s the life that I live — constantly trying to find a way to secure funding for brand and awareness when most people care about driving revenue. I think it’s going to be a great conversation, because your presentation, defending brand awareness, is an important one.
As marketers, we all know that brand awareness for an institution is extremely important. But we also have the realities of CFOs and presidents wanting to know attribution, to get the data around movement, and that’s not always going to be the case. So I’m curious — when you’re sitting across the table from a CFO or senior leader who just wants to see direct attribution or immediate returns, how do you make the case for brand awareness?
Kristin Nichols
You’re going to have soft returns if you don’t do brand awareness first. That’s just it. You have to lay the foundation by getting the brand out there effectively before you can start really building a growth model.
So what I did at MCLA was utilize national surveys and national data from trusted partners and say, this is what it looks like overall. I did this really with an enrollment lens, but you can certainly do it with a development lens or with other populations as well — just to see what it is that people are looking for.
And then I started to build brand awareness through omnichannel marketing: storytelling, media relations pushes that we could take omnichannel, and a strong social media presence, really leaning into the trends and telling what it was like at MCLA. That’s how you start building traction and awareness. The growth marketing came after.
So to validate that it was working, you say: this is where we’re setting the table based on the data we have nationally. Give us four months. Just give us four months to start getting the brand out there.
Jeff Holeman
And for me, I’m regularly trying to plant the seed with leaders who I work with that awareness fuels performance. You can’t have one without the other. If people don’t know you exist, how do they choose you? It’s a very basic concept, so you plant that seed regularly. But then I also look for what data I have to show that we need to focus on it.
A good example would be this past year. Our college opened two new campuses, in Jacksonville and Miami, at the same time. We did market research, and I took that data and shared it with leadership so they understood what we were facing. In Jacksonville it was less about who we were or that we existed, and more about the fact that we were going to be there and offering degrees there — a different kind of awareness you have to put forward.
In Miami it was a whole different story. We had no presence in Miami at all. Of course people knew what the University of Florida was — our market research there showed something like 99% awareness and preference, better than any of the schools down there, because UF is so big. But for Warrington, it was around the 40th percentile. I actually thought it was going to be even worse, so I was pleasantly surprised.
What that showed is that we had a big lift to get to the point where people were thinking about us for a business college. And if they’re not thinking about us, they’re not going to be thinking about us in a hyper-competitive market like Miami, where you have everyone from Northwestern Kellogg to Babson to Northeastern to Vanderbilt building down there, plus all the Florida-based schools. So you have to make the case, and you’ve got to constantly find the data to do it.
Kevin Tyler
Have you ever found yourself in a scenario where brand awareness investments were reduced in favor of performance, because performance was easier to measure? And if so, can you share some of the specific consequences — and whether leadership ultimately recognized what it had sacrificed?
Kristin Nichols
Yeah, I stepped into that. What we were seeing was that marketing dollars were being spent just to try to attract more leads, and it was leading to cost-per-lead bloat. We weren’t seeing strong conversion, and that was a real challenge. What they were doing was spending more money to attract new students, and the brand initiative really wasn’t present.
So when I stepped into the role I said, look, we need to reallocate funds here, because doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is the definition of insanity. Let’s not choose that definition.
We reallocated the money and put it into the website. That was such a wise idea. We revamped the top pages of the website. We put student stories on it, so that instead of talking to students the way we were doing it as administrators, we had students talking to prospective audiences — including development.
Making sure our website was buttoned up as much as possible, so that when people encountered the brand they could go to the website and actually see it, turned out to be a much better converter than spending money on names that weren’t converting. That was something we changed drastically. We reduced our purchases by two-thirds so that we could fund a digital strategy to support the brand.
Kevin Tyler
Jeff?
Jeff Holeman
Sure. I inherited a very similar situation in my current role. The team before had spent years focused on performance and enrollment at the expense of brand. It just chose not to focus on brand and awareness. But the enrollment KPIs were showing that we were spending too much — just like what Kristin mentioned, our cost per lead was exorbitant. In some cases, thousands of dollars per lead. It’s crazy that they were spending that much. In all fairness, I think there may also have been an incomplete understanding of how to do it differently.
But when people just don’t know who you are, it’s harder to convince them to choose you — and when you’re going against national competitors, that space gets very expensive and very competitive, very fast. So it wasn’t working for us, because we hadn’t taken the time to let our key constituencies know we were there. And the story was the same as every other business school out there. It was a very beige message. Very bland. That doesn’t work, and that’s why the performance isn’t going to work out for you.
When we switched it and started doing more on awareness at the same time as the performance work, the leads took off and the number of applications increased. That’s the way you have to do it.
[Ad break]
Announcer
Higher ed marketing teams are expected to deliver greater results with fewer resources. Ambio EDU makes that possible. As the premier performance TV platform engineered specifically for higher education, it connects streaming TV advertising to real enrollment outcomes. The Ambio platform pairs precise audience targeting with in-house creative production, then uses matchback attribution and AI-optimized analytics to show exactly what drives applications. Every impression is measured, every dollar is accounted for, every campaign is sharpened over time. No guessing, no vanity metrics — just the right students reached, and the proof to back it up.
Kevin Tyler
How do you help leadership understand the risk of losing visibility in key markets, especially when prospects aren’t going to interact with the brand for maybe several years?
Kristin Nichols
For my situation, that had been happening for a decade, and they were trying to recover — working so hard to do that — so it was a little bit of a different situation.
I told them early on, when I was contracting with them rather than being an employee as I am now, that my contract was up. I had to get bold. I kind of had to shake them awake and say, look, this is the reality. I said: you’re silent in the market. And unless you do something to change that, you’re not going to succeed. And I walked away.
This school is vitally important to me. All of my life joys are because of MCLA — my family, my career, my children. And they came back and said, we hear you, and we understand that we need to do something different. So where do we start? How do we do this, and how do we modernize? For me it was a little bit of a difference, in that I had to make them realize it and have them figure it out.
Jeff Holeman
Very similar situation, just as Kristin said. The hard part was what we were seeing in the graduate space, which is pretty much where we’re marketing in the performance area for a business program. The average time from lead to enrollment was about two years. And we were only at the very beginning of that two-year period, so we were losing them further down.
Doing an analysis of the data and looking at what was happening to the leads they were getting — and why they weren’t applying or enrolling — I think the answer was that there were no touch points, because the effort was all at the top. That’s all it was. It stopped, and then the people went away. So of course, if they don’t hear about you and they’re not ready to make that decision yet…
And especially given what we saw on that average lead-to-enrollment time: across the board it was two years, which matches national data as well. So I had to make that case and show that data, and then say, we have to be marketing year-round. We can’t just do it right here. And it’s not even just the advertising — it’s the various touch points, our drip campaigns, how we’re constantly staying in touch with them through our paid efforts but also through our own initiatives.
Kevin Tyler
Keep them engaged over time.
Jeff Holeman
Exactly, exactly.
Kevin Tyler
What measurement frameworks, research, or evidence have you developed to demonstrate the impact of reputation-building activity?
Jeff Holeman
Historically — even in my own time there — I think we spent too much time focused on the typical performance indicators: how many applications, how many students enrolled. And that was to my own detriment, because I’m advocating that we need to fund awareness, but the KPIs and indicators I was giving were all about performance, because that’s what they want to know. They want to know how much revenue is coming from these campaigns, and we have a great program that was showing that. But what I realized is that it wasn’t helping me from the awareness perspective.
So I went back and said, okay, our paid campaigns are working particularly well, and that’s where we really want to focus because we’re spending so much money there. We need to do this differently. What can our dashboard look like?
We’ve redeveloped it, and now we look at it as three distinct areas. We still have the performance factors we had before. Then we layered in, at the very top, the awareness indicators — often the vanity things you think about, but they’re important. What are the impressions? What are the clicks we’re getting? How many leads are being established? And then the next thing we added was engagement in the middle: how many people actually go to your website, how often are they there, what actions are they taking, what additional pages are they engaging with, how are they engaging with our social? We look at all of those together, and there’s a better story to tell.
Kristin Nichols
The vanity metrics are something where clicks aren’t going to tell you everything anymore, and organic needed to have a bigger stance in the strategy. So we spend a lot of effort on media, really getting our stories out — where are our young alums working? Going out and talking to the young alums who are at ESPN, talking to the ones who are at Paramount and in different places like that. Not students — young alums.
Then also looking at our faculty: what are they doing that’s really interesting? Let’s get some media around that, let’s see if we can get some traction, because we know that a media hit is third-party validation for artificial intelligence.
So we spent a lot of time on that organic storytelling and omnichanneling it with social media. We’d develop a story, put it on our website, get it out on our channels — but then, where are we getting it elsewhere? How can we get the hits so that it gets some organic traction on Reddit? And then Claude and GPT and all the other things pick it up and say, MCLA is a great place for political science, Samantha Petty is a faculty member there and she’ll be teaching you, Sam studies gender in politics, and here’s where she’s been quoted. Those are the types of things where we’re really starting to see the brand awareness build on itself.
Kevin Tyler
That’s really smart. For marketers who might find themselves defending awareness initiatives, what advice would you give them?
Kristin Nichols
Just keep swimming — Dory, from Disney. I used that at a different conference, in a session I did. But really: persistence overcomes resistance. You’re not going to get a yes right away. It’s not going to be easy. Keep chipping away at it. Keep a level head on your shoulders.
And I promise you that when you reflect on how much you’ve changed things for the better, it’s going to be significant. I’ve only been doing this for two and three-quarter years, and most days I want to bang my head against a brick wall because it’s so frustrating. But when I look at what we’ve done at MCLA — the overall buzz we’ve created, that people are actually talking about us now, and that’s helping to fuel enrollment because of all of it — it’s really happening. The board sees it, our new president sees it, and everybody’s got a little pep in their step. So if I can leave anyone with that: stay focused.
Jeff Holeman
Get the idea stuck in your leaders’ heads that awareness fuels performance. They need to be repeating that again and again and again, and they have to understand it and believe it. You also have to find a way — one that works for you and works for your leaders — to find some kind of data to prove it that they’re going to believe, and that will help you over time.
Another step that’s been particularly helpful: treat your CFO as a partner.
Kristin Nichols
Yes. Yes.
Jeff Holeman
My CFO and I don’t always see eye to eye, and he doesn’t give me everything I want. But he’s a regular participant in the meetings we have with our paid media agency partner. He sits in, he understands it, he knows what we’re talking about. And he wants to be there — he has an interest.
I think that’s very positive, because he understands what we’re trying to accomplish and he’s seeing the results we’re getting. So if I want to do something new, he knows that we’re going to deliver. Having that partnership and that transparency makes it easier when I go back and say, okay, I need this now. There’s just more faith. That’s an easier sell — you don’t have to go through the entire story.
Kevin Tyler
This would not be a Higher Voltage episode without our closing question, which is: what do you think higher ed is going to look like in the next five or ten years?
Kristin Nichols
It’s hard to predict with AI, huh?
We know that the demographic cliff is here, and it’s here until 2041. So I think what we’re going to see is an adaptation of traditional models at an accelerated pace. We’re going to have to have more flexibility to give the consumer what they want, instead of boxing them into what we are. I don’t know exactly what that looks like, but I do see it being an accelerating force for higher ed. Higher ed is going to have to adapt at a quicker pace. We are a slow industry, and it’s time to put a little pep in the step and take a look at the audiences. Customization is key, and we need to start customizing our offerings.
Jeff Holeman
I’m going to take a slightly different stance. Particularly in the work we do in marketing and branding, I think what’s going to change in higher ed is the idea that experience matters more than ever now.
I think we’re going to see higher ed adapt the business model of, say, healthcare, where brand experience is so critical — tying your brand into the experience that students have. Because if they don’t have a great experience and our brand keeps failing, they’re going to choose to go elsewhere. It’s really about who we are and what we’re about, not just what we’re saying in the marketing. It’s going to be lived and proven in all the interactions people are having. I think our industry is ripe for that kind of change, and I think people are going to start demanding better accountability and better experiences.
Kevin Tyler
I just got a book delivered two days ago called Experience Is Everything, and I cannot wait to devour that and then bring it to this podcast.
Kristin and Jeff, thank you so much for joining us on Higher Voltage. It was really great to meet you today. Have you already presented, or not?
Kristin Nichols
We did, we did — this morning.
Kevin Tyler
Well, how did it go?
Kristin Nichols
I think we killed it. We had a lot of great energy, a lot of great questions. You know your session went well when there’s a line of people wanting your attention. And people are still coming up as we walk through, saying thank you for what you did, I learned so much, that was so good, I want to talk more — and a lot of connections on LinkedIn. Those are the things that tell you you did something right.
Kevin Tyler
It’s one of my favorite things about AMA. We know that the community exists when we’re at our desks and on our campuses, but when you’re here you get to feel it even more amplified. I’m glad that you had that experience. I’m sure the presentation was great.
Jeff Holeman
It was electric. We got some applause and lots of people waiting to talk to us afterward. It’s always a wonderful few days to be with everyone. So, thank you, Kevin.
Kevin Tyler
Thank you.


