Skip to main content

Awareness Fuels Performance: Defending Brand Investment in Higher Ed

When leadership demands immediate ROI, how do you defend long-term brand building?

21 minutes
By: Higher Voltage

Recorded live at the AMA Higher Ed Symposium, marketing leaders Kristin Nichols and Jeff Holeman share their playbook for defending brand awareness investments against the pressure for immediate performance metrics.

When campus leadership is hyper-focused on immediate enrollment metrics, advocating for long-term brand awareness can feel like an uphill battle. But as Jeff Holeman, CMO at the University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business, frequently reminds his stakeholders: “Awareness fuels performance. You can’t have one without the other.”

In a special on-location episode of Higher Voltage recorded at the AMA Higher Ed Symposium in Denver, host Kevin Tyler caught up with Holeman and Kristin Nichols, the first-ever CMO at the Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (MCLA). The two had just delivered a highly praised presentation on defending brand awareness and reputation inside performance-obsessed institutions.

Both leaders inherited scenarios where institutional dollars were heavily skewed toward lower-funnel performance marketing at the expense of brand building. The result was the same on both campuses: exorbitant cost-per-lead bloat, poor conversion rates, and a brand message that was entirely absent in key markets.

To turn the tide, Nichols and Holeman had to make data-driven cases to their respective leadership teams. Nichols used national survey data to prove that MCLA was essentially “silent in the market,” ultimately convincing leadership to reallocate two-thirds of their lead-purchasing budget into strengthening the website and building organic, omnichannel storytelling. Holeman used market research to demonstrate that despite the University of Florida’s massive footprint, the Warrington College of Business lacked the specific program awareness needed to compete against national heavyweights in new markets like Miami.

By successfully arguing that it takes multiple brand touchpoints to nurture a prospect over the typical two-year graduate enrollment cycle, both leaders secured the funding needed to build a brand foundation. Most importantly, those investments have paid off, with substantial increases in inquiries and enrolled students at both institutions.

Higher Voltage

Higher Voltage

Podcast

Higher Voltage explores what’s working, what’s not, and what needs to change in higher education. Higher Voltage isn’t just for anyone who works in higher education—it’s for anyone who is interested in or cares about higher education.

Newsletter Sign up!

Stay current in digital strategy, brand amplification, design thinking and more.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Also in Podcasts

What Netflix’s ‘On Campus’ Teaches Higher Ed About Authentic Storytelling

Almost Friday Media’s Alex Edge joins “Higher Voltage” to explore how Netflix’s raw, student-led series about college football culture is rewriting the rules of higher ed marketing.

Podcasts /
By: Higher Voltage

Nostalgia Is Not a Strategy: Redefining the Higher Ed Marketing Function

Katherine Primus, VP of Marketing and Communications at Holy Family University, explains how campus marketing teams can evolve from internal order-takers to strategic, revenue-generating partners.

Podcasts /
By: Higher Voltage

New Compliance Tactics: Dissecting Higher Ed’s Changing Legal Terrain

From Title VI investigations at elite law schools to “Compact 2.0,” guest Neal Hutchens joins Campus Docket to unpack the unprecedented legal tactics shifting the political and regulatory landscape of higher education.

Podcasts /
By: Campus Docket

What Netflix’s ‘On Campus’ Teaches Higher Ed About Authentic Storytelling

Almost Friday Media’s Alex Edge joins “Higher Voltage” to explore how Netflix’s raw, student-led series about college football culture is rewriting the rules of higher ed marketing.

Podcasts /
By: Higher Voltage

Nostalgia Is Not a Strategy: Redefining the Higher Ed Marketing Function

Katherine Primus, VP of Marketing and Communications at Holy Family University, explains how campus marketing teams can evolve from internal order-takers to strategic, revenue-generating partners.

Podcasts /
By: Higher Voltage

New Compliance Tactics: Dissecting Higher Ed’s Changing Legal Terrain

From Title VI investigations at elite law schools to “Compact 2.0,” guest Neal Hutchens joins Campus Docket to unpack the unprecedented legal tactics shifting the political and regulatory landscape of higher education.

Podcasts /
By: Campus Docket