Riding Out a Cat5 Administration

Crisis leadership, culture wars, and why higher ed must lead—not retreat—in a polarized world.

55 minutes
By: Campus Docket

 

Higher ed’s hurricane season.

When Walter Kimbrough calls leading a college in today’s climate “like riding out a hurricane,” he’s not speaking metaphorically—at least, not entirely. The longtime HBCU president, now interim leader of Talladega College, knows a thing or two about steering institutions through storms, both literal and political.

On the latest episode of Campus Docket, co-hosts Eric Kelderman and Scott Schneider sit down with Kimbrough for a wide-ranging conversation on crisis leadership, culture wars, and how higher education can better model civic dialogue in a post-truth world.

Kimbrough’s reflections are shaped by decades in leadership, including his tenure at Dillard University following Hurricane Katrina. That experience, he says, informs how institutions must navigate today’s existential threats, such as the federal scrutiny targeting elite universities, growing public skepticism of DEI efforts, and free speech tensions amplified by political polarization.

“There’s a real danger in remaining silent,” Kimbrough says. “Higher ed has to be the place where we learn to argue both sides, model that behavior, and call out disinformation when we see it.”

He’s candid about the failings of institutions too, acknowledging that many DEI programs lack clear goals or measurable impact, making them easy targets for critics. He argues for internal accountability and more creative pedagogy to challenge assumptions and promote ethical thinking, including his own classroom experiments using hip hop and court cases.

The conversation also turns deeply personal. Kimbrough and Schneider swap stories about New Orleans, where culture seeps into every exchange, from strangers calling you “baby” to the character-filled eateries like Neos. It’s a reminder that place and personality matter in education too.

In a moment when many college leaders feel pressure to lay low, Kimbrough’s message is clear: Now is not the time to retreat. “If Harvard loses,” he warns, “it’s bad for everybody.”

The Docket

Campus Docket

Campus Docket

Podcast

Campus Docket cuts through the week’s headline‑grabbing lawsuits and federal actions to explain how fast‑moving legal shifts are rewriting the playbook for higher education.

Newsletter Sign up!

Stay current in digital strategy, brand amplification, design thinking and more.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Also in Podcasts

Trusted Voices with Holden Thorp. To the right is an image of Holden Thorp a man with short gray hair wearing glasses and a blue suit with blue shirt and maroon tie, holding a microphone.

Choose Your Damning Wisely

Speaking out on high-profile issues like executive orders and policy changes is a delicate task—but in higher ed leadership, silence can be just as damning as saying the wrong thing.

By: Trusted Voices
A picture of Allen Adamson, a man with short gray hair wearing a blue shirt and black coat, and Kevin Tyler, a bald man with a dark mustache wearing a checkered shirt.

In a Word-Of-Mouth Business, No One Shares Average – Allen Adamson

Kevin and Allen discuss the importance of focusing on a clear and distinct mission, rather than diluting the institutional identity with multiple conflicting messages.

By: Higher Voltage
Graphic design showing a black-orange background next to a picture of a woman with dark skin, brown hair, and a black-colored suit jacket with a yellow scarf; the word Trusted Voices appears on the background; beneath that is the name 'Valerie Seares Ashby.'

Valerie Sheares Ashby on Mentorship, Team Building and Measures of Success

President Valerie Sheares Ashby of the University of Maryland, Baltimore County discusses mentorship, team building and measures of success.

By: Trusted Voices
An image of Dr. Belle S. Wheelan, president of the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools, Commission on Colleges. She is an older, dark-skinned woman with short gray hair wearing a pink blazer and multicolor silk scarf.

Feet to the Fire

Dr. Belle S. Wheelan joins Teresa and Erin to discuss accreditation, the responsibilities and roles of accrediting bodies and the plans for higher ed under a second Trump administration.

By: Trusted Voices